Jump to content
India-Drive
  • Welcome!

    Welcome to India-Drive, Road trips and travel group. Please register to join us.

  • 2
SK01

Replacing Honda City with Ford EcoSport. Worthy or Not?

Question

Now I can say, it's a necessity for me to replace my Honda City with a new car and that should surely be a SUV or at least a crossover. 

 

Me and my father do many roadtrips, we travel much, but never did we face problems with the Honda City. That's a beautiful car. A car that introduced me to the world of revvs and performance. This car performs extremely well on the highways, effortlessly cruises at 140kmph. 

 

But as the trips kept  increasing, rather the exploring part kept  increasing, the need for a SUV started. This beauty isn't able to take bad roads well. We always feel bad for abusing the car taking it to badly laid roads. We scraped it's under body 4 times in one year which stopped is from doing further exploration trips on this car. 

 

Here, the need of a SUV or a crossover came up. 

 

A brief about the car:

 

It's a 2014 Honda City VX (topend) i-VTEC which comes with a cruise control, sunroof, auto climate control, rear AC vents, 2 airbags, ABS with EBD, ventilated leather seats, all leather upholstery. 

 

A car with class leading comfort, luxury and space. (Here I don't consider any of the Maruti Suzuki cars because they don't even come near to any of the C segment cars in the market)

 

The  boot is so huge that it takes almost everything that a family carriers during long drives without compromising on the second row leg room. 

 

So, an upgrade or even replacement means that the vehicle should offer few more latest features including those which my City offers. Or at least should offer those which already exists. 

 

Now as I'm already a satisfied and happy owner of Ford Freestyle my second car, I want my next car to be a  Ford and not others even if they're better.

 

Test drove the Tata Harrier, Hexa, XUV5OO (ridiculous interior plastic quality) Jeep Compass, Hyundai Creta. All these cars are no doubt awesome. Of all these I loved the Hexa. But as said I don't want to come out of Ford and want to be a Ford owner always. So, here comes the problem. I'm in a confusion of what to do.

 

Shall I wait for the new SUV launch from Ford in collaboration with Mahindra?

 

Or take the EcoSport?

 

Is EcoSport really a proper replacement or upgrade to my City?

 

Does it offer more than what my City offers including space?

 

Or at least what my City offer? 

 

all these are everytime running in my head. And a thought of restricted rear space, rear AC and boot space is stopping me from taking the EcoSport. I request EcoSport owners to give me some detailed information of EcoSport and request others to help me get the answers to the questions that are running in my mind. 

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

9 answers to this question

Recommended Posts

  • 1

Hey @SK01, Firstly I wouldn't call this an upgrade as City falls on a higher side compared to the Ecosport considering the price and dimensions. As your requirement seems more inclined towards the in-car space, I recommend you to go for another option as Ecosport feels very claustrophobic in it's rear.  I would suggest you to go with S-Cross instead of Ecosport which lie on the similar price line.

  • Like 1
  • Thanks 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 1

Considering your budget to wave around 10- 12L, The current available models that I would like to suggest to you as per your requirements are TATA NEXON, SUZUKI S-CROSS and FORD ECOSPORT.

Model expected to be launched in the same segment by the end of 2nd quarter or 3rd quarter this year is the HYUNDAI STYX.

 

12 hours ago, SK01 said:

Any information on upcoming Ford SUVs?

 

I don't sense any new FORD successors in this segment to be launched until 2020.

  • Like 1
  • Thanks 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 1

When you can consider Ecosport, I feel you can definitely consider S cross as it is bigger then creta in dimensions :D  If budget isn't your constraint to replace your city, You can also wait for the KIA SP2 new entrant or Harrier.

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 1
17 hours ago, SK01 said:

What about Safari Storme? A true SUV and even I can get at an amazing price. Or wait for new SUV launches by Ford till 2020 and use my Freestyle for road trips until then. The GC of my Freestyle is 190mm which can go over bad patches and a smaller car means less headache in narrow areas. 

I checked up yesterday about Safari Storm, on 2019 models only 25K discount is offered across all variants. on 2018 models insurance at 14990 and exchange bonus of 20K is being offered. Malik Cars offered 70 K discount on 2018 models and on 2019 model 25 K only. 

 

  • Like 2
  • Thanks 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 1
On 3/16/2019 at 1:23 PM, Shekar said:

I checked up yesterday about Safari Storm, on 2019 models only 25K discount is offered across all variants. on 2018 models insurance at 14990 and exchange bonus of 20K is being offered. Malik Cars offered 70 K discount on 2018 models and on 2019 model 25 K only. 

 

 

I would suggest you to avoid Safari.
It is at the end of its life cycle. 

Even If you get 2+ lakhs discount, i would suggest to avoid it. 

 

On 3/13/2019 at 11:58 AM, SK01 said:

Is EcoSport really a proper replacement or upgrade to my City?

 

EcoSport is downgrade to City.

If space is not a constraint, EcoSport is an excellent cross over. 

 

If you are looking a vehicle for exploration drives, none of the above listed cars come under that category. 

Start looking at 4wd options. 

 

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 1
On ‎3‎/‎15‎/‎2019 at 8:10 PM, SK01 said:

What about Safari Storme?

Hands Down 'NO' to that... :D You can rather consider other options.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
Thanks for the suggestion @sagar

 

same thoughts about City here. My requirements are good ground clearance and it’s capabilities on bad roads. City is really a bad vehicle for exploring and you know what all challenges we face during exploring. If not a 4*4 I’m looking for a vehicle that can go where the City can’t because of its GC. 

 

Any information on upcoming Ford SUVs? 

 

My requirements are good GC, space, safety, bad roads capability (if not a 4*4 it should be better than sedans) and high speed stability. 

 

On ‎3‎/‎15‎/‎2019 at 8:41 AM, sagar said:

Considering your budget to wave around 10- 12L, The current available models that I would like to suggest to you as per your requirements are TATA NEXON, SUZUKI S-CROSS and FORD ECOSPORT.

All those doesn’t feel as premium as City. Will wait for the Hyundai Styx or else postpone the idea and wait for some time... I considered S-Cross as a replacement for my WagonR alternative to Freestyle while buying. Can’t imagine another cross hatch😑

Tata Nexon and EcoSport are really good vehicles but will definitely be smaller than my City.

 

 

On ‎3‎/‎15‎/‎2019 at 10:28 AM, sagar said:

If budget isn't your constraint to replace your city, You can also wait for the KIA SP2 new entrant or Harrier.

What about Safari Storme? A true SUV and even I can get at an amazing price. Or wait for new SUV launches by Ford till 2020 and use my Freestyle for road trips until then. The GC of my Freestyle is 190mm which can go over bad patches and a smaller car means less headache in narrow areas. 

On ‎3‎/‎15‎/‎2019 at 10:28 AM, sagar said:

definitely consider S cross as it is bigger then creta in dimensions :D 

Yes bigger only by dimensions but smaller in looks and looks more like a hatchback. Also I don’t want to consider Maruti Suzuki. 

 

22 hours ago, Ranger said:

 Start looking at 4wd options. 

 

21 hours ago, sagar said:

You can rather consider other options.

Will check Duster AWD or else wait for 2020. Will not be in a hurry else I'll miss a beautiful car. 

 

 

22 hours ago, Ranger said:
On ‎3‎/‎16‎/‎2019 at 1:23 PM, Shekar said:

I checked up yesterday about Safari Storm, on 2019 models only 25K discount is offered across all variants. on 2018 models insurance at 14990 and exchange bonus of 20K is being offered. Malik Cars offered 70 K discount on 2018 models and on 2019 model 25 K only. 

 

 

I would suggest you to avoid Safari.
It is at the end of its life cycle

 

21 hours ago, sagar said:

Hands Down 'NO' to that... 

Just eager to know the reason why many are against taking a Safari at this point. Is it only because it's being discontinued or any other reason such as engine, safety, old platform, etc...?

  • Like 3

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
On ‎3‎/‎14‎/‎2019 at 8:02 PM, SK01 said:

Just eager to know the reason why many are against taking a Safari at this point

 

Tata Motors Quality and Reliability of this batch of cars is one reason as it is going to fade away pretty soon as their new leg is booming at the moment.

Safari no doubt is a great car. Only thing is that the quality of plastic is cheap. The suspension and braking system are very stiff. The car is very much spacious where in 7 can sit but, its 3rd row side seating is no way impressive as how it is felt in an Innova.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
10 hours ago, sagar said:

 

Tata Motors Quality and Reliability of this batch of cars is one reason as it is going to fade away pretty soon as their new leg is booming at the moment.

Safari no doubt is a great car. Only thing is that the quality of plastic is cheap. The suspension and braking system are very stiff. The car is very much spacious where in 7 can sit but, its 3rd row side seating is no way impressive as how it is felt in an Innova.

Okay. So Safari is also ruled out. 

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
You are commenting as a guest. If you have an account, please sign in.
Answer this question...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


  • Similar Content

    • By SK01
      Exploring Yanam Part 1
       
      Origin: Ramachandrapuram, East Godavari, Andhra Pradesh.
      Destination: Yanam, Puducherry.
       
      Route Taken: Ramachandrapuram - Tallapolam - Draksharamam - Kuyyeru - Yanam
      Start Time:5:10AM
      Distance: 27KMS
      Time Taken: 1hr 
      Car: Honda City VX i-VTEC
      Mileage: 13.2KMPL
      Road Condition: Mix of good, average, bad and worst. 
      Scenic Views: Single lane roads with beautiful scenes at either side of the roads. The roads are surrounded by lush green farms on either side. 
       
      Trip Report
       
       
      Yanam, the place that I first visited in 2013, when I was 17. And this time again I wanted to visit the place only to know it better and love it more...
       
      Started early in the morning at 5:10 and reached the area in 1hr. 
       
      The only thing I thought I could do in the place is to take the initial sunrise photo touching the waters. That's a beautiful sight and I never missed that. But surprisingly this time I got more than what I expected. I got to know about the area more and explore the area and the backwaters. This time, unfortunately, I could take my favourite shot, the sun touching the waters because of clouds. But got a chance to explore the area a bit. 
       
      It was 7:00 AM, the sun just started rising pushing the clouds aside. And there I saw a person in a white shirt and white pant, assumed him to be a local and approached him to inquire more about the place. To my surprise, he turned out to be the government boat operator. Upon asking him, he arranged a boat ride into the waters and at 7:15 I was on the boat moving gently on the backwaters. 
       
      The boat driver Ramakrishna, is a very nice guy. I finished taking photos and started talking with him. he spoke many things, from the political situation in Puducherry and Andhra Pradesh, their lives, the local MLA and not to forget, the insider information about the place.  Yanam, a very beautiful place, mostly unexplored and left undeveloped. "Yanam chala manchi ooru Saru, Kani Chala mandi teliyaka raru. Tourists perigite maku income perugutundi" said the boat driver. 
      Yanam indeed is a really beautiful place, there are many places to explore from Yanam. 
       
      The first one, 
       
      Bhairavapalem Mangrove Forests (Where we can find many rare migratory birds. It takes 2 hours to come and 2 hours stay on this island. Total of 6 hours. Price for 10 is 6000 INR) Koringa Mangrove Forests And many small unexplored islands (We can find many migratory birds)  
      I think the area should be developed, but that development shouldn't destroy the natural beauty and serenity of the place. The local activities early in the morning, sunrise, birds chirping and the fishing activities are really beautiful and the development should not destroy these...
       
      Part 2 coming soon... I'll be writing about the places that in have visited in part 2.  
       
      Places to stay:
      The Regency Hotel (best for families as per trip advisor) Sarva Inn Puducherry Government Guest House   
      Few Pictures
       
       
       

       

       

       

       

    • By Ranger
      Go-Karting tracks in Hyderabad
       
      1. Chicane Circuit (Leonia Shameerpet)
      Location: https://goo.gl/maps/7z3VGq29ibL2
       
      Length :
      1.2 kilometers (600 meters recreational : 1200 meters professional) 
       
      Timings:
      Weekdays: 10 AM to 12 Midnight Weekends: 10 AM to 12 Midnight Monday Holiday  
      Pricing
      Baby Kart - 8 Laps INR 280/- Level 1 - 7 bhp - 12 Laps INR 370/- Level 1 - 7 bhp 10 mins INR 540/- Twin Kart - 7 Laps with Max of 5 Mins. INR 530/- Micro Max Kart INR 660/- Level 2 - 16 bhp 10 mins INR 1050/- Level 3 - Rotax (7 laps) INR 900/-  

       
    • By Ranger
      Finally got a chance to fix my bumper scratches.

       
      Two weeks back I had small bumper damage.
      Minor bumper crack Broken clips Deep scratches
       
       
      Visited showroom:
      Replace rear bumper  Repaint rear bumper Need to order bumper Insurance claim charges Three days time (once the bumper is available)  
      From the past 15 years,
      I never gave my car outside the showroom.
      All the repaint jobs are done at showroom.
       
      Last weekend, I decided to explore lower Tankbund options.
       
      I contacted my friend who live around that area,
      He said most of them does the work well.
       
      We picked a shop that my friend visits for bumper repairs. 
       
      Quote given was 1200/-
      I was in shock :p (my aim was to get it done under 2.5k)
      Price was too tempting to leave,
      I gave a go ahead without any bargain.
       
      Steps
      Reached paint booth at 10AM They remove the fuel cap Took it to paint shop  Got the color premixed They applied some Patti Some rubbing work done Removed tail lamp Fixed the broken bumper clamp Tail lamp fixed back  
      It was like a war zone, 5 members working on it.
      He spotted few scratches on front bumper Asked me another 300/- to fix :o I gave a go ahead Masked all the parts They sprayed 4 different types of paints At 11AM it is done and I out  
      Pros:
      Cheap Quick 100% colour matching Cons:
      Long term reliability Not so professional Ideal for only bumper damages Finishing is not so great, I can feel some rough edges.  
      Ideal place to fix scratches for a 5+ year old cars.
      For new cars it is always better to claim the insurance and fix it. (If you need professional quality)
       
      Removed the fuel cap to get the correct paint

      Applied some patti

      Removed the tail lamp to fix the bumper clamps from inside (to avoid external screws)
      Rubbing is done.

      Had few bumper scratches at the front corner,
      Shop owner asked for another 300/- bucks to fix it, since the paint will be left over.
      I gave a go ahead. 

      They sprayed around 4-layers

      Let the pint dry

      Final output : Front bumper

      Rear bumper

       
      Once I get time,
      I will click pictures in the sunlight for the analysis. 
  • Our picks

×